Harness vs. Dog Collar: Which is Best for Your Dog?

Dog Harness?  Or Dog Collar?  Which should you attach the leash to?

When it comes to walking your dog, one of the first decisions you need to make is whether you should attach your leash to a dog harness vs. collar. 

Both options have their advantages, and the right choice depends on your dog’s behavior, breed, and specific needs. In this article, we’ll break down the key differences between collars and harnesses, and help you determine which is best for your furry friend.

Whatever option you choose for you and your dog, make sure you follow all safety and care instructions.  We have an article about how to wash your dog's harness or collar and check for damage.

The Case for Collars

Dog Collars are a classic and convenient choice for many dog owners. They’re simple to use, lightweight, and serve multiple purposes beyond walking.  There are many cute dog collars that serve as a conversation starter or help your dog look more frendly.i

Pros of Collars:

• ID and Tags: Collars are perfect for holding ID tags, rabies tags, and other identification, ensuring your dog can be easily identified if they get lost.

• Ease of Use: A collar is quick to put on and take off, making it a great option for short trips or everyday wear.

• Variety of Styles: From flat buckle collars to martingales, there are plenty of options to suit your dog’s needs and personality.

Cons of Collars:

• Risk of Neck Injury: Dogs that pull on the leash or lunge during walks can experience strain on their neck, leading to potential injury.

• Not Ideal for Pullers: For dogs that pull excessively, collars don’t provide adequate control and can exacerbate pulling behavior.

• Breed-Specific Concerns: Certain breeds, like Greyhounds and Whippets, have delicate necks that make collars less suitable.

Types of dog collars:

2 Hounds Design offers 3 types of dog collars

• Martingale Collars - best known for use with Sighthounds and dogs with necks larger than their heads.  This is how we got our start and our name - from Iceman and Paradise, Alisha's retired racing greyhounds.
• Buckle Collars - this is what most people think of when you say "dog collar", it has a side release buckle that opens and a D-ring to attach the leash.
• Buckle Martingale Collars - the best of both worlds, great for dogs with heads bigger than their necks, but when you still want to use a martingale style collar.

The Case for Harnesses

Harnesses have grown in popularity, especially for dogs that pull or have respiratory issues. They distribute pressure more evenly across a dog’s body, reducing the risk of injury.

Pros of Harnesses:

• Better Control: Harnesses provide more control, making them ideal for training, walking in busy areas, or managing reactive dogs.

• Reduced Strain: Unlike collars, harnesses take pressure off the neck and distribute it across the chest and shoulders, making them a safer option for pullers.

• Supports Training: No-pull harnesses, like the Freedom No-Pull Harness, can discourage pulling behavior and promote better leash manners.

• Ideal for Small or Delicate Dogs: Harnesses are a great choice for toy breeds or dogs prone to tracheal collapse, as they avoid putting pressure on the windpipe.

Cons of Harnesses:

• More Complicated: Harnesses can be trickier to fit and adjust properly, especially for first-time users.

• Not Always Suitable for All-Day Wear: While comfortable for walks, some harnesses aren’t designed for extended wear.

• Bulkier: Harnesses are generally less lightweight and can take up more room in storage or travel bags.

Dog Harness vs. Dog Collar?  Key Factors to Consider

1. Your Dog’s Behavior

• If your dog walks calmly on a leash, a collar may be sufficient.

• If your dog tends to pull, lunge, or react to distractions, a harness provides better control and safety.

2. Health and Breed Considerations

• Dogs with respiratory issues, delicate necks, or prone to tracheal collapse will benefit more from a harness.

• For breeds like Greyhounds or Whippets, a martingale collar or a well-fitted harness is often recommended.

3. Walking Environment

• For short trips or low-risk environments, a collar might be the simpler option.

• In crowded areas, on hikes, or during training sessions, a harness provides more security and control.

Why choose between a harness vs. collar?

Collars and harnesses don’t have to be mutually exclusive. Many dog owners use both and many veterinarians recommend a collar for ID and a harness for the leash.

• Collar for Identification: Keep a collar on your dog with their tags at all times for safety.

• Harness for Walks: Use a harness when walking or training your dog to ensure comfort and control.

Conclusion: What’s Right for Your Dog?

Choosing between a harness vs. collar ultimately depends on your dog’s specific needs, behavior, and health. For many dogs, a harness is the safer and more comfortable option, particularly for pullers or dogs with delicate necks. However, collars remain a convenient and functional tool for everyday identification.

If you’re unsure which is best for your dog, consult with your veterinarian or trainer. And remember, whether you choose a collar, a harness, or both, the key is ensuring a proper fit and using positive reinforcement to make every walk enjoyable for you and your pup.

Explore our collection of collars and harnesses, including the Freedom No-Pull Harness, to find the perfect gear for your dog!